Convicted animal abuser — Lakeland, FL
Prison ends. Fines get paid. This page does not expire.
Convicted animal abusers will call this site home, and they will never leave.
Polk County, Florida
No verified photo of Joel Gutierrez has been published in an official public record or news report (checked Oct 29, 2026).
If you have a photo of this offender, please email it to contact@thecruzwatch.com so it can be verified and added to this page.
In September 2024, on North Turkey Creek Road in Lakeland, Gutierrez demanded payment for work and threatened to shoot a horse unless he was paid. He shot the horse, a mare named Ms. Mo; the bullet fractured her leg and she had to be euthanized.
| Conviction | He pleaded guilty to four felonies: aggravated animal cruelty with a weapon, discharging a firearm from a vehicle, grand theft of an animal, and breaking or injuring fences containing animals. |
|---|---|
| Sentence | Sentenced in October 2026 to 1 year in prison followed by 5 years of probation, with $15,000 restitution for the horse's value, a $2,500 animal cruelty fine and restitution for veterinary bills; he must also register on the animal abuse registry and complete a mental health evaluation, anger management and community service. |
| Verified | Oct 29, 2026 |
The Cruz Watch is a volunteer-run registry. Our petition asks for a public registry of convicted animal abusers, with their addresses published, so no shelter, breeder, or neighbor has to guess who they are dealing with. Add your name.
Sign the petitionThe Cruz Watch is the world's first & only global registry of convicted animal abusers. Every listing rests on public records and published reporting, with sources linked on the record. If we made a mistake, a verified error comes down: see the Remove Me page on the main site. A factually accurate entry does not come down, and listings are never for sale.