The Cruz Watch

Sharon Duttle

Convicted animal abuser — Mesquite, NM

Prison ends. Fines get paid. This page does not expire.

Convicted animal abusers will call this site home, and they will never leave.

Doña Ana County, New Mexico

No verified photo of Sharon Duttle has been published in an official public record or news report (checked Oct 11, 2026).
If you have a photo of this offender, please email it to contact@thecruzwatch.com so it can be verified and added to this page.

After reports of dogs kept in a manner consistent with staged dogfighting preparations, animal control checked her Mesquite property (warrant executed Sep 15–16, 2008). Thirty-eight dogs were removed; per the appellate opinion, 31 had to be euthanized and 2 more died in the shelter from severe heartworm disease and related complications, with individual dogs documented emaciated, scarred, tick-infested, and untreated.

The record

ConvictionConvicted by a jury (Third Judicial District Court, Doña Ana County) of 1 count of dogfighting, N.M. Stat. § 30-18-9 (fourth-degree felony); 1 count of conspiracy to commit dogfighting; 8 counts of extreme cruelty to animals, § 30-18-1(E) (felonies); 10 misdemeanor cruelty counts; and 1 permit ordinance count
SentenceThe sentence has not been published in the appellate opinion or in the news sources checked; this card will be updated if the Third Judicial District judgment is obtained
AppealAffirmed on appeal, State v. Duttle, 2017-NMCA-001 (cert. denied Aug 8, 2016). No live appeal
VerifiedOct 11, 2026

Sources

Make this registry the law

The Cruz Watch is a volunteer-run registry. Our petition asks for a public registry of convicted animal abusers, with their addresses published, so no shelter, breeder, or neighbor has to guess who they are dealing with. Add your name.

Sign the petition
See this entry in the full registry → Search the registry

The Cruz Watch is the world's first & only global registry of convicted animal abusers. Every listing rests on public records and published reporting, with sources linked on the record. If we made a mistake, a verified error comes down: see the Remove Me page on the main site. A factually accurate entry does not come down, and listings are never for sale.